Home » Republican Messaging

Category Archives: Republican Messaging

Trump cancels execution livestream, and we think we know why

Dumpster fire instead of firing squad

Donald Trump has canceled Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s plan to livestream the December 3 firing squad execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan. Trump reportedly changed course after supposedly just learning Hasan uses a wheelchair. That is hard to believe, since Hasan has been paralyzed since his 2009 attack.

In fact, the plan drew loud opposition from across the political spectrum. First, critics, including Republican Senator Thom Tillis, pointed out that it copied the playbook of dictatorships like Iran and Afghanistan. As Republican Congressman Rob Bresnahan put it, the focus should be on justice for the victims and their families, not entertainment.

Moreover, as described by Archbishop Paul Coakley, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, the livestream execution idea was “a barbaric promotion of a culture of death.” More than 60 soldiers had voiced religious objections to taking part in a livestreamed firing squad.

Critics also feared the plan would hand America’s foes a propaganda weapon. Conservative talk show host Erick Erickson warned that the livestream would give Hasan the “platform for martyrdom he wants” and predicted that the video would inspire more terrorists to attack Americans. Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson and Senator Kevin Cramer gave similar warnings as well.

Trump’s “October Surprises” are falling flat

No October Surprise party for GOP

An “October Surprise,” a late-breaking revelation or dramatic development that shakes up an election campaign, has become a staple of American politics. In 2016, for example, just 11 days before Election Day, FBI Director James Comey announced that the FBI was examining newly discovered emails potentially related to Hillary Clinton’s private email server, thrusting the controversy back into the headlines and hurting her election chances.

This year, with the 2026 midterm elections less than three weeks away, Democrats lead the generic congressional ballot by 8.8 points, according to Nate Silver’s October 13 polling average, while Donald Trump’s approval rating is under 40%. Those numbers give Trump and his allies a powerful incentive to change the political narrative before voters go to the polls.

And right on cue, the Trump administration has been making dramatic announcements and taking controversial actions. For instance, on October 9, Trump announced an agreement with Russian President Vladimir Putin to increase Russian diesel supplies to global markets, promising relief from soaring fuel prices. However, critics say the initial shipment amounts to less than one day’s worth of U.S. consumption, and therefore would have little impact on prices. American motorists and truckers continue to face high fuel costs, as do consumers paying more for many goods that rely on fuel for production, transport and/or delivery.

Facing midterms losses, Republicans scramble to look like they’re doing something

Gas prices become dangerous for GOP

Democrats have hammered Republicans on affordability, especially gas and food prices, as the main issue of the 2026 midterms. They picked a good theme, as a plurality of 47% of registered voters call the rising cost of living the single most important factor in their midterm vote. Democrats now hold their largest lead yet in the polls.

Data centers are a second hot issue, with a large majority of Americans opposing one being built near them. This opposition cuts across party lines. Reflecting one of the major concerns, sixty percent of Americans think that a new data center in their community would raise their electric bills. Voters are also concerned about data centers’ water use, their noise and light pollution, and their effect on residential property values.

For the Republicans, however, time to address these concerns is running out. Election Day is Nov. 3, only 33 days away. Early voting began on September 18 in a number of states, with more being added to the list regularly. The U.S. House already left town until after the midterm elections. The U.S. Senate is scheduled to stay in session only through tomorrow.

Democrats are fighting a media war with no army

“We can build a better system”

As we have stated here before, Republicans have spent decades building a media machine reaching into nearly every corner of American life. Fox “News” is only the start. Sinclair Broadcast Group owns local television stations that reach nearly four in ten American households with its conservative-biased programming. Add Newsmax, OAN, the Daily Wire, the Tucker Carlson Network, AM talk radio, newspapers such as the Washington Post (owned by Jeff Bezos), the Wall Street Journal and the New York Post (both controlled by News Corp. i.e. the family of Rupert Murdoch), and even CBS News now in right wing hands, and you get Uber drivers reciting right wing talking points to captive customers. Many non-conservatives therefore get exposed to this Republican ecosphere as well, as the massive reach of GOP talking points means they become the actual discussion topics for many issues.

Democrats have no comparable media structure. As a result, conservative outlets can seize upon a topic and hammer it far longer than any Democratic effort could sustain. The tactic often follows a simple pattern: Republicans take an isolated incident, strip it of context, and use their media machine to present it as proof of a nationwide crisis, often using their invented false narratives such as “Scary Brown People”.

Is Epstein the big issue for the 2026 elections?

People have thoughts about Epstein

Right now, there seem to be two main issues that the news media and the public are talking about. The first one is the thuggish behavior of ICE agents attacking and imprisoning protesters, non-criminals, and even children. However, Donald Trump‘s administration is making it as difficult as possible for people to protest, film, or even write publicly about the illegal ICE activities.

The second issue the news media and many voters are talking about is the Epstein files. There, the Trump administration is having less success keeping the story under control. In recent testimony before Congress, U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi tried her best to protect Trump and make the issue go away, at one point even saying that Americans should not be talking about the horrors of the Epstein files because “the Dow is over 50,000 right now.” However, every day, it seems additional prominent people become implicated in the Epstein story to one degree or another, from being friends or socializing with Jeffrey Epstein or riding on his plane, all the way to allegations of raping underage girls. In other countries, Epstein files revelations have taken down, demoted or sullied the reputation of high-placed officials and prominent figures, including:

Thanksgiving 2025 political talking points are out, but will they help?

Will facts get through to them?

Just in time for Thanksgiving 2025, the ACLU and Everytown for Gun Safety have released their dinner table talking points, for those fair-minded folks (i.e. Democrats) to use against their bull-headed relatives (i.e. Republicans) when the conversation, like the food, heats up.

First up is ACLU, which states that its goal this Thanksgiving is “countering misinformation”. To that end, it has sent around a “Holiday Conversation Guide“. The guide talks about Donald Trump‘s threats to free speech, including to TV hosts such as Jimmy Kimmel, and to student protesters. It also mentions Trump’s deployment of federal enforcement agents and military troops around the country. Then the ACLU’s guide provides some tips, such as “Emphasize the facts and shared values”. For example:

Protests against the Trump administration’s abuses and policies have been overwhelmingly peaceful. The First Amendment protects the right to organize and protest peacefully, and law enforcement can’t break up a gathering simply because a few people have broken the law.

Meet the real centrist

Centrist Bunny

The word “centrist” gets thrown around a lot lately, but on the political left, it is more likely to describe a moderate Democrat. What is the difference? That can be found by meeting someone we know named “Carl.” He is perhaps like other U.S. voters today. For starters, his political and policy information arrives largely from cable TV “news.” Unfortunately, that often involves superficial shiny objects that originate from the Republicans, from Hillary Clinton‘s emails to Hunter Biden‘s laptop to Sydney Sweeney‘s clothing, and more. Even the supposedly non-Republican TV “news” networks like CNN and MSNBC spend lots of time on these GOP distraction squirrels.

10 years ago, Carl was pretty firmly in the Republican camp (though we’re not sure where he was before that). The GOP’s 40-year Culture War apparently had won him over. Carl felt that the Republicans somehow appealed to his manhood. Living in a red state, he also fondly talked about his gun collection. When Donald Trump came along as a presidential candidate in 2015 and subsequently won in 2016, Carl supported him.

Now, however, Carl has shifted his stance, or feels that the Republicans have shifted too far to the right and away from him, or both. At a recent lunch, Carl first said that Trump is an idiot. However, Carl went on to describe political positions that appeared to choose almost evenly from the very different Democratic and Republican Party platforms and agendas. After saying he can’t stand Trump, he said that the Democrats should not be operating “sanctuary cities” that give free stuff to illegal immigrants. After saying he loves “Obamacare” i.e. the Affordable Care Act, Carl stated that Hunter Biden is a problem. While Carl expressed great concern about Trump’s and the Republicans’ move to fascism and their destruction of the balance between the three branches of government, somehow that wasn’t enough to turn Carl blue.

What Trump’s war on Iran distracts us from

2020 antiwar protest, Milwaukee, WI

Donald Trump‘s bombing of Iran has knocked many other stories off the news headlines. That seems convenient at a time when those other headlines weren’t good for Trump and the Republicans. Recall what was happening, and being talked about, just a few days earlier:

—Trump’s birthday parade using the U.S. military as props was a big dud. Attendance was dismal. Trump fell asleep. Secretary of State Marco Rubio was looking bored and was yawning. Moreover, the parade was greatly overshadowed by …

–The “No Kings” protests, which attracted millions of peaceful, committed demonstrators around the country, and galvanized Democrats and others to continue their resistance against the Trump administration’s worst abuses.

–Trump’s TACO nickname (which stands for “Trump Always Chickens Out”) on tariffs.

–Trump’s negative poll ratings.

—Record-high food prices, including soaring beef prices, reminding us that a centerpiece of Trump’s 2024 presidential campaign was the promise to bring such prices down right away.

–The Republicans’ so-called “Big Beautiful Bill,” a giant debt disaster of tax cuts for the wealthy offset by cuts to environmental protection, Medicaid and elsewhere, that is highly unpopular.

In the face of all this bad news, it’s no wonder that Trump started an impulsive and illegal war. But Middle East wars have a habit of driving U.S. presidents’ popularity down over time. Speaking of which, Democrats should now ask Trump, “why did you bomb Iran when there was no intel to support it?” and “where is Iran’s uranium now?”

Photo by Susan Ruggles, used under Creative Commons license. https://is.gd/uNkjn3

Top liberal blogger says Democrats need to keep it simple

Markos Moulitsas of Daily Kos

Markos Moulitsas, founder and publisher of the the popular liberal political blog Daily Kos, was a guest on the “Make It Plain” podcast with host Rev. Mark Thompson a/k/a Matsimela Mapfumo yesterday, and had much to say about how Democrats are communicating in the current political climate. Mostly, according to Markos (who usually goes by his first name, or his U.S. Army nickname “Kos,”) the Democrats are falling down on the job, which is hurting them at election time:

We’re in trouble if we don’t learn how to talk to people and focus on the issues they care about.

Cynical, even ridiculous, Republican bill name

Republican bill should include this name

Right now, the Republicans in Congress are moving a budget bill forward, passing it in the U.S. House by one vote and sending it to the Senate. Republicans convened their House Rules Committee at 1 a.m. on Wednesday to consider the bill, and they passed it in the middle of the night. Given that Congress typically works only four days a week and takes umpteen paid vacations, you know this is a lousy bill when Republicans have to hide their actions in the dark.

Among other things, the bill would drastically cut Medicaid, supplemental nutrition, and renewable energy programs. According to Republican plans, the savings from such cuts would not be used to reduce America’s government debt, but rather to give the money to wealthy individuals and corporations as giant tax cuts. The result, according to CBS News, could add trillions to our deficit.